Question
Why are necessities, such as food, clothing and shelter mostly affordable, but not health insuarnce?
Can't figure it out. Here in Tempe if a man were to work 80 hours a week and earn minimum wage with no benefits (remember, we have nine-percent unemployment now, higher than Belgium, Australia and Norway, mind you), he could bring in about $2,000 per month before taxes. He can get a studio for under $500 or a rented room for a little less; one month's worth of groceries, if purchased at the 99 Cent Store or Food City, could run him $250 per month, and a week of clothing purchased at Goodwill might run him about $100. All affordable, many options for the low-wage earner. Now, this guy actually works for a living maximum hours, so he doesn't qualify for state aid (I've looked into it, that salary is too high), and many jobs don't offer benefits, particularly low-skilled ones, so what's he to do? Let's say he has a pre-existing condition, therefore, he is either denied insurance outright or charged well over $1,000 per month (look at Blue Cross/Blue Shield, Golden Rule, Aetna, Cigna and United). So, he works for a living, doesn't smoke, no woman will have sex with him, he has no children, he doesn't do drugs, he has no gadges (iPod, computer, stereo), no car (he takes the bus), even after all that, he's still screwed. He needs preventative care, not emergency ward treatment as that's not financially viable for America long term, so what does he do: job offers no benefits, is denied or overcharged for health insurance, can't find a job with benefits, state won't provide the working man with state insurance...shouldn't he just quit working and become the welfare leach that conservatives revile because hard work is getting him nowhere?
2 months ago - 2 answers
Best Answer
Chosen by Asker
If his medical costs are under 1000k per month, then he should not purchase insurance. If he has expenses more than this, I doubt he is working 80 hours a week (check your math as I think you are shorting him some pay). Insurance is to protect against unforeseen occurances, not known costs. If your auto insurer knew that every month, you would get into an accident, and your 10k car would be replaced, how much would you expect to pay for insurance? Same thing applies to health insurance. If you think you can make a business paying out 50k a year in benefits, while taking in only 45k in premiums, good luck. It is always easier to spend someone elses money (what the govt does). If you feel so passionately about having others pay for health insurance, take your money and give it to someone leaving a hospital. Me, I think the govt taking over 50% of the money I earn is enough. What is really funny about insurance, I have it, good plan, and is still cheaper to pay cash at Wal-mart to get my eyes checked, than to use insurance. And has been for a decade.
Source(s)
Small business owner, who offers health insurance, tired of everyone thinking they understand how best to spend money I've earned.
by snpuck
2 months ago
Asker's Rating: ![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
Other Answers
People of low income (the working poor) can qualify for general relief or welfare and food stamps (EFT in CA) and medical.
by car253- 2 months ago



