Yahoo! Answers

Question

Roommate Question: Can she do this?!?

Can she do this to me?! My roommate recently financed a used truck and just today got back from a 2 week cruise. She's on this kick live life like today is the last day thing cause she had a friend die. Well, anyway I wrote her this email while she was gone. Good news is! Remember how I wanted to ask my boss to borrow money to pay off my truck payment? Well I finally did it, and he said yes! BUT he only loaned me half of it. So, I have to make payments to my boss to pay him back, and I have to make payments to the truck to pay off the balance. I figured out all my bills and at the bare minimum, I have 395 left over every month. My boss is getting 200/month, and the truck people want 247/month. It's a little bit over my budget but I can make it work by giving myself less spending money, and living very frugally. I will have everything paid off by April, 2010. Debt-free by my 30th birthday! So that's the good news! On to the bad news. I'm going to ask you to take the cable box out of my room, maybe the TV, too. Cutting out the Direct TV bill will help me to come up with that little bit of money that I'm short. And I haven't even figured in the cleaning lady at all. I'm not going to be able to pay for her anymore. I'll be more than happy to do the cleaning myself! Actually last night I did the bathroom tub and sink, tonight I'm sweeping and mopping, and I'm going to clean out the refrigerator. I think having the TV gone will be a good thing for me because I'll less distracted and be able to study better. We can plan it out so it's the end of the billing cycle, and I'll of course pay the following bill. Hope you're having fun! I'm super excited that I'm finally getting this debt taken care of and my ex now has NO reason to bother me! Yay! Ok, so that's the end of my email.This is what I got in reply: I sympathize and understand what you're going through because I also am going through tough times with my expenses as well. I need someone who can help me more financially than less, therefore, I decided that in order for me to catch up with my expenses and climb out of debt, I would have to raise what I'm asking in rent for the room. At this point, I need someone who is financially able to pay more a month, so that I won't have to struggle with carrying such a heavy financial burden. I realize that this this would hard for you to fit into ur budget, so I understand completely if you have to look for another place. Well, talk more when u come home. Okaaay so wtf is this?! She wants me to become a part of her income? What do I do? Just because she's living beyond her means does that mean I should have to help her live her lavish life style? I'm trying to get out of debt by cutting costs! I'm so mad. No, I'm not on the lease. Thanks everyone for your support I am so distraught over this! No, I cannot find this anywhere else. She found the apartment at a great price because she is friendly with the landlord. But everything happens for a reason. I hope she can't find a roommate in time to help her with bills, and I hope that they are the worst roommate ever who trashes the house and never pays bills on time just like herself! Ha! Everyone please feel free to email me because I'd love to talk about it some more. On a happier note, my boyfriend of 2 years has agreed to look for an apartment with me, I've been trying to get him to move out for the longest! Maybe it was God's will?

5 months ago - 8 answers

Best Answer

Chosen by Asker

well her reason is a bit flawed becauser her income problems are not yours. That does not justify increase in rent. Now having said that if she can easily find someone to rent room for the new price she is asking then that is the going rent and you will have to pay or move out. So the real question is what is the going rent for a a similar place to stay? Can you easily find anther place for current rent amount? if you can, then tell her no you will not agree to rent increase. You can tell her that is not the going rent rate rigtht now and you will not accept that increase.

by David Z

5 months ago

Asker's Rating: 

Other Answers

If you signed a lease with your roomate that stated the amount for rent over a given period of time, then she cannot charge you more rent out of the blue. However, if a lease was not signed, then unfortunately she can do whatever she pleases.

by The Chad- 5 months ago

a verbal agreement IS a contract, just harder to prove than one in writing....did you make rent payments to her? do you have a paper trail? those are things you need to prove what the agreement was on you living with her. Maybe give a lawyer a call, they will do free consultations.

by Amy C- 5 months ago

Look for a new place with someone else. With the way she is living I would get away from her asap, she will drag you down. If she continues to go down this road you both will be looking for a new place to live. If you get into a legal dispute as others leaned towards, I doubt you will want to live with that person...so my advice still stands move out. Oh and good job on getting yourself out of debt.

by pagodaboy2001- 5 months ago

If you are not on a lease and have no written agreement with her then you are there on what is called a month to month lease. Meaning in most states she can do whatever, whenever she wants as she is the lease holder or owner. If she wanted to she could have you removed just cause she is the one with the name on the paperwork. Best bet. Move! Good luck!

by robnrobn2000- 5 months ago

Ridiculous. That is all I have to say. The good old American habit; buy **** you can't afford... I personally think you shouldn't have to put up with that. That is way out of line. Being financially independent is the number one thing to become in this world today. Too many people out there are heartless and inconsiderate of people's needs. You said something about studying? I take it you are in college or some type of other schooling? Um, there is a large financial demand there. Not for a damn truck. Or, in this case, an increased "rent" BECAUSE of a truck and a 2 week cruise. Independence. Independence. Independence. Make your own budget, make your own way of spending. Don't let people decide that for you.

by Jon- 5 months ago

She is retaliating against you for not wanting some of the amenities in the apartment! What a snatch! Can you find a new place for what you pay now? If so, move out and then she will really be screwed! However, if you did not sign an agreement with her, then its going to be hard to prove anything in a court of law. If I were you, I would contact a lawyer to see what rights you have under the law. They will give you a free consultation in most cases.

by Emmers- 5 months ago

Take part of the money your boss gave you and find your new home... Immediately before things get worse. It never works out living with family, friends, or roommates for that matter. Lesson learned. Good luck!

by Brandy- 5 months ago