tax decisions
Question
Short sale/deficiency question?
A friend of mine bought a house a few months before he got married for $180K in his name only. The value of his house subsequently dropped to around $70K later in the year. He decided to try for a short sale on his property and stopped paying his mortgage, solely because of the bad investment decision, not because he couldn't afford it. Meanwhile, he bought a house with his wife (under her name only) which is much larger at a much lower price. Now, the bank wants to come after him for the deficiency of $110K. He's been talking to bankruptcy attorneys and said he'll definitely have to file bankruptcy. He's hoping he can file ch7 and not have to pay anything, but I told him ch7 is a lot harder to qualify for now and he probably won't be able to. I'm thinking he'll have to pay a portion of it back, and taxes on the rest he doesn't owe, but I'm just an accountant so this is the extent of my knowledge on the subject. What's the likely outcome of this situation? Will he have to pay some or all of the money back? Will he lose his new house (doubtful) or cars? Both he and his wife have car loans through the mortgage lender so this is a big concern for him. Thanks for the help so far, this is in Cape Coral, FL. He does have some money in the bank, and wage garnishment was a concern for him. I told him not to take out the 3yr ARM, then not to short sale the home, but he's an idiot. He did all his banking with the lender, but they have frozen his accounts. So now he's trying to put everything in his wife's name to save his assets. I'm not sure if that will help. Also, the car loans are separate loans with the old house's lender, not the new lender.
5 months ago - 4 answers
Best Answer
Chosen by Asker
short guess. If he's still working they will come after him. It's no different than not paying your credit card. It is real money he borrowed. They'll go after his paycheck.
by zocko
5 months ago
Asker's Rating: ![]()
![]()
![]()
Other Answers
Several points: To the extent he is insolvent, the amount of debt forgiven is not necessarily taxable. Depending on the state, community assets may be attached including the wife's house. Without knowing the state, we can't determine what assets are exempt and what aren't
by zeuz- 5 months ago
Wow, he is making bad decision after bad decision here. Of course the lender is going to come after him, and depending on the outcome of the BK, he is going to have to pay back whatever is issued in the judgment. A foreclosure and a bankruptcy on his credit report. That is going to hurt for YEARS.
by godged- 5 months ago
Unless he is in a community property state, the house should be safe. If you mean that the car loans are a part of the mortgage ( a HELOC?) then that was a very unwise decision on their part. To lose a house due to a car is terrible! If you mean they have separate loans on each, but just with the same bank, then the house is safe as long as the payments are made on it.
by knowitall- 5 months ago



