Question

Business Network Server?

Our business has several locations and we need some type of server/network to connect all the locations. What are the differences between a physical server located in our main office and a virtual server hosted by a some other companies? What are the pro and con for each of the 2 types of server/network? How about security? Will a physical server be more secure than a virtual one? Or vise verse? And the cost? Which is cheaper overall? Thank you very much for your information.

6 years ago - 3 answers

Best Answer

Chosen by Asker

I will address the points one at a time.


1) The main difference between your own server in your main office and a hosting company is who maintains it.

Do you have someone at your office who knows how to set up and maintain your network? If not expect to pay between $75-90K/yr for a good network admin, more if you choose to go with a Unix/Linux box. Also don't forget the cost of the hardware. A high end server will easily cost $4-5000. This doesn't include the cost of running your network drops/routers/switches/etc if the infrastructure is not already in place.

Even if you go with external hosting you will need to have a plan in place to do things like replace network cards and resolve other local hardware issues.

If the hosting company maintains it you have to look at several things.
a) how reliable are they? If your server is only up 80% of the time you will have problems.

b) What type of support do they provide? Can you call them at 3am and if so do they have someone around who has a clue how to help you?

c) You also need to look at whether you will have your own box at their location or if your data will be sharing a machine with several other companies. a dedicated machine will generally be faster and more secure but will cost you more.



2) Security
A machine at your main office would probably be more secure IF you have someone who knows what they are doing (see the $90K paycheck above) and knows how to lockdown your network, configure firewalls, etc. If you are just going to have Bob the computer geek from accounting set things up you will end up with problems.

The main security concerns with a hosting company usually involve just how much of you proprietary data you are willing to trust them with although you do want to make sure they have a good track record of locking down their servers.

Cost:
If you already have an IT department in place, its usually cheaper to run your own server. If you dont then you will have to do a cost/benefit analysis to see what it will take to get you where you want to be and then compare that with the costs/risks associated with external hosting.

You could easily spend 10's of thousands of dollars in setup costs alone. I strongly suggest hiring someone to come in and take a look at your current setup and requirements as doing it wrong initially can cause some extremely expensive problems once you get further down the line.

6 years ago
  • Email

Other Answers

You do not have enough information to answer your question.

You would need to know:

How much CPU do you need?
How much disk space to you need?
What type of network traffice do you need?
When does the server need to be up ? 24/7/365?
All of these requirements will change the price dramatically - and I mean by 500 - 1000% sometimes.


My recommendation -have your IT people develop a really good request for proposal, send it out, and get responses back - then you can compare the different price points and offerings of companies that do the outsourced model.

Then compare what it would cost to house it internally - if you don't have an IT department, then you would have to contract a time and materials person / people to maintain your network and boxes.

by girlwhoknowsitstrue - 6 years ago

Ok, what you need is a domain. a domain will allow all the computers to connect to a central location..

on the otherhand, a local area network is local group of computers connected either peer to peer, or client/server...

a Wide area network is a group of locations connected through a domain using the client/server method. THe local area would rely on the WAN for connections and files. If it goes down, so do you.

now, there are ups and downs for each. if you are using a WAN, you can have more communication, and more synchronization.. but if your primary connection goes down, and you dont have a secondary, youll be stuck with your LAN.

your lan, is faster, and designed more for just office use. network printers, and such. They are nice, but if you have more than 1 centralized connection, example, a few towns over, or say one in new york, one in chicago, a WAN would be better.

You can find a lot of articles on microsoft, or from linux; i prefer linux, but microsoft is so much better..

Either way you will still need a physical server. whether it is in your local network, or wide network. The virtual part would mean that there is a server, somewhere, on the network WAN, or LAN, and that the computers can connect to it. It would still need to be physical..

Now, a LAN would be CHEAPER by far. Less required, but if you're looking to expand, each office will need their own LAN, and if you need a lot of communication, youll be sending a lot of emails.

ontop of that, you can have a virtual private network (VPN). Set up a connection to a server and have each computer connect to it.

There is so much to explain, but i cant in a post, so browse the internet for keywords like.. VPN, LAN, WAN, Windows Server 2003, Domain, Workgroup.. those should help!

by #Red- - 6 years ago

Recommended Articles

  • Monitors show value of Facebook, Inc. stock before closing bell at NASDAQ Marketsite in New York
    Facebook faces crucial week after modest debut

    NEW YORK (Reuters) - Newly issued shares in Facebook Inc may have a hard time in the coming week if lead underwriter Morgan Stanley stops supporting the stock and managers lower down in the IPO book who … More »Facebook faces crucial week after modest debut

    Monitors show value of Facebook, Inc. stock before closing bell at NASDAQ Marketsite in New York

    NEW YORK (Reuters) - Newly issued shares in Facebook Inc may have a hard time in the coming week if lead underwriter Morgan Stanley stops supporting the stock and managers lower down in the IPO book who were hoping for an early surge decide to get out before going underwater. Facebook on Friday sold 421 million shares of …

  • Employees play table tennis inside the headquarters office of Alibaba (China) Technology Co. Ltd on the outskirts of Hangzhou
    Alibaba buys back 20 percent stake held by Yahoo for $7.1 billion

    SHANGHAI/NEW YORK (Reuters) - Chinese Internet entrepreneur Jack Ma is buying back up to half of a 40 percent stake in his Alibaba Group from Yahoo Inc for $7.1 billion, in a deal that moves the Chinese … More »Alibaba buys back 20 percent stake held by Yahoo for $7.1 billion

    Employees play table tennis inside the headquarters office of Alibaba (China) Technology Co. Ltd on the outskirts of Hangzhou

    SHANGHAI/NEW YORK (Reuters) - Chinese Internet entrepreneur Jack Ma is buying back up to half of a 40 percent stake in his Alibaba Group from Yahoo Inc for $7.1 billion, in a deal that moves the Chinese e-commerce leader closer to a public listing. Under the agreement, Yahoo will sell half its stake in Alibaba for at least …

  • The U.S. flag hangs outside the New York Stock Exchange
    Wall Street Week Ahead: Market is oversold, but major signs say "sell"

    NEW YORK (Reuters) - Normally a big decline would set up Wall Street for a technical rebound. But that may not be the case this week, even after the market posted its worst weekly loss for the year and … More »Wall Street Week Ahead: Market is oversold, but major signs say "sell"

    The U.S. flag hangs outside the New York Stock Exchange

    NEW YORK (Reuters) - Normally a big decline would set up Wall Street for a technical rebound. But that may not be the case this week, even after the market posted its worst weekly loss for the year and the S&P fell for six straight sessions. With the corporate earnings season drawing to an end and recent U.S. economic data …

  • To match Insight SAMSUNG/
    Apple, Samsung CEOs set for court talks

    SAN FRANCISCO (Reuters) - The chief executives of Apple Inc and Samsung Electronics Co Ltd are used to running the show at their global tech empires, but they will be in for a different experience when … More »Apple, Samsung CEOs set for court talks

    To match Insight SAMSUNG/

    SAN FRANCISCO (Reuters) - The chief executives of Apple Inc and Samsung Electronics Co Ltd are used to running the show at their global tech empires, but they will be in for a different experience when they arrive at a San Francisco federal courthouse on Monday. Apple's Tim Cook and Samsung's Choi Gee-sung, whose companies …

  • In this photo illustration, a Facebook logo on a computer screen is seen through a magnifying glass held by a woman in Bern
    Facebook shares could fall below IPO price: Barron's

    (Reuters) - Shares in social media company Facebook Inc could fall below the initial public offering price of $38, Barron's wrote in its May 21 edition. Facebook saw its shares rise a scant 0.6 percent … More »Facebook shares could fall below IPO price: Barron's

    In this photo illustration, a Facebook logo on a computer screen is seen through a magnifying glass held by a woman in Bern

    (Reuters) - Shares in social media company Facebook Inc could fall below the initial public offering price of $38, Barron's wrote in its May 21 edition. Facebook saw its shares rise a scant 0.6 percent to $38.23 on Friday in the first day of trading. The stock stayed above the $38 IPO price, supported in the market by the …

  • Euro zone row gets fat pay rise for German workers

    BERLIN (Reuters) - A record-breaking pay deal will give millions of German workers their biggest rise in wages in two decades, boost consumption in Europe's biggest economy and help towards adjusting the … More »Euro zone row gets fat pay rise for German workers

    BERLIN (Reuters) - A record-breaking pay deal will give millions of German workers their biggest rise in wages in two decades, boost consumption in Europe's biggest economy and help towards adjusting the regional imbalances that have caused severe tensions within the euro zone, analysts said on Sunday. Germany's largest …

  • Insight: China pays high price to spare state firm from bankruptcy

    WEIFANG, China (Reuters) - The Chinese official was adamant the city of Weifang would keep its rayon factory open, noting that local authorities had just stepped in to help the plant's owner repay $60 … More »Insight: China pays high price to spare state firm from bankruptcy

    WEIFANG, China (Reuters) - The Chinese official was adamant the city of Weifang would keep its rayon factory open, noting that local authorities had just stepped in to help the plant's owner repay $60 million in commercial paper. The bailout averted what would have been China's first ever bond default and was good news …

  • Weaker euro zone nations need more support from core: UK

    LONDON (Reuters) - The euro zone can protect its currency if its stronger countries provide more support for the weaker to help them deal with their problems, British finance minister George Osborne said … More »Weaker euro zone nations need more support from core: UK

    LONDON (Reuters) - The euro zone can protect its currency if its stronger countries provide more support for the weaker to help them deal with their problems, British finance minister George Osborne said in a newspaper on Sunday. The future of Europe's 17-country single currency bloc is under threat from a political stalemate …

  • China's Wen urges more support for growth

    BEIJING (Reuters) - China's premier called for additional efforts to support growth on Sunday, signaling Beijing's willingness to take action after a recent series of economic indicators suggested that … More »China's Wen urges more support for growth

    BEIJING (Reuters) - China's premier called for additional efforts to support growth on Sunday, signaling Beijing's willingness to take action after a recent series of economic indicators suggested that the world's second-biggest economy will slow further in the second quarter. "We should continue to implement a proactive …

  • Visitors look at monitors displaying market indices at the Tokyo Stock Exchange in Tokyo
    Shares, euro steady but Greek worries weigh

    LONDON (Reuters) - European shares took a breather from last week's sell-off and the single currency steadied on Monday, but investors were wary after a weekend meeting of Group of Eight leaders failed … More »Shares, euro steady but Greek worries weigh

    Visitors look at monitors displaying market indices at the Tokyo Stock Exchange in Tokyo

    LONDON (Reuters) - European shares took a breather from last week's sell-off and the single currency steadied on Monday, but investors were wary after a weekend meeting of Group of Eight leaders failed to ease concerns about the risk of Greece exiting the euro. The FTSE Eurofirst index of top European shares edged up 0.2 …

  • U.S. President Obama hosts an expanded G8 meeting with African and other leaders during G8 Summit working lunch at Camp David
    G8 growth talk leaves wary markets awaiting action

    (Reuters) - A pledge by leaders of industrialized nations to help the troubled world economy is unlikely to herald quick new action by Europe on its debt crisis, meaning more uncertainty for nervous financial … More »G8 growth talk leaves wary markets awaiting action

    U.S. President Obama hosts an expanded G8 meeting with African and other leaders during G8 Summit working lunch at Camp David

    (Reuters) - A pledge by leaders of industrialized nations to help the troubled world economy is unlikely to herald quick new action by Europe on its debt crisis, meaning more uncertainty for nervous financial markets. The Group of Eight economies stressed on Saturday that their "imperative is to promote growth and jobs", …

  • Monitors show value of Facebook, Inc. stock before closing bell at NASDAQ Marketsite in New York
    Nasdaq to revamp system after tech problems on Facebook IPO: WSJ

    (Reuters) - The Nasdaq is planning to revamp its systems for handling stock offerings after acknowledging that technology problems had affected trading in millions of newly issued Facebook shares on Friday, … More »Nasdaq to revamp system after tech problems on Facebook IPO: WSJ

    Monitors show value of Facebook, Inc. stock before closing bell at NASDAQ Marketsite in New York

    (Reuters) - The Nasdaq is planning to revamp its systems for handling stock offerings after acknowledging that technology problems had affected trading in millions of newly issued Facebook shares on Friday, the Wall Street Journal reported. Individual investors were left in the dark for hours on Friday about whether their …

  • Australia to seal trade deal with Malaysia

    CANBERRA (Reuters) - Australia will sign a free trade agreement(FTA) with Malaysia on Tuesday in a move it hopes will add new momentum to stalled bilateral trade talks with other key Asian trading partners. … More »Australia to seal trade deal with Malaysia

    CANBERRA (Reuters) - Australia will sign a free trade agreement(FTA) with Malaysia on Tuesday in a move it hopes will add new momentum to stalled bilateral trade talks with other key Asian trading partners. Australia is still negotiating free trade deals with South Korea, Japan and China, with progress in reaching agreement …

  • An undated handout picture shows the newly appointed CEO of Adam Opel AG, Stracke
    Opel CEO faces workers over possible plant closure

    FRANKFURT, Germany (Reuters) - The head of General Motors unit Opel sought to allay workers' fears that the automaker plans to shut one of its four German plants as it pulls production of the Astra, its … More »Opel CEO faces workers over possible plant closure

    An undated handout picture shows the newly appointed CEO of Adam Opel AG, Stracke

    FRANKFURT, Germany (Reuters) - The head of General Motors unit Opel sought to allay workers' fears that the automaker plans to shut one of its four German plants as it pulls production of the Astra, its best-selling model, from the country. Opel Chief Executive Karl-Friedrich Stracke is under pressure from GM to end heavy …

  • A grounded Qantas aircraft is seen parked at Heathrow Airport in west London
    Qantas to cut another 500 maintenance jobs

    MELBOURNE (Reuters) - Australia's top airline Qantas Airways said on Monday it is eliminating 500 jobs by merging maintenance facilities to save up to A$100 million ($98.4 million) annually, as high fuel … More »Qantas to cut another 500 maintenance jobs

    A grounded Qantas aircraft is seen parked at Heathrow Airport in west London

    MELBOURNE (Reuters) - Australia's top airline Qantas Airways said on Monday it is eliminating 500 jobs by merging maintenance facilities to save up to A$100 million ($98.4 million) annually, as high fuel costs and weak demand take a toll on airline profits. Qantas, which is emerging from a costly industrial dispute, said …