Question

Old TV commercials on youtube?

OK, here's my question. I put up on youtube my favorite TV commercials ever, about 2 years ago. Yes, I don't own the rights to it it's over 10 years old, (Superbown 1997)

(See it below it's still floating around youtube ---> youtube.com/watch?v=ho9WiVrYRv8

This commercial is a parody of the YMCA they don't use the same lyrics. I did name the file "YMCA Pepsi Bears Superbowl 1997"

This week it was taken down by youtube due to a copyright infringement notice. (here it is)----> "This is to notify you that we have removed or disabled access to the following material as a result of a third-party notification by Scorpio Music S.A. / Can't Stop Productions claiming that this material is infringing"

Why in the world would the publishing company care about this? I really doubth they are loosing sales due to a TV ad parody. I'm really tired of media companies complaining about trivial crap like this. If this is the case, shouldn't the YMCA organization complain to Scorpio?
So the question s are, how many years does it take for TV ads to be in the public domain

And was this really infringing to the publishing company Scorpio Music S.A. / Can't Stop Productions or are they being stupid by over reacting.
Honestly, who is getting hurt from this?

4 years ago - 3 answers

Best Answer

Chosen by Asker

It is not a matter of who is getting hurt but is one of the copyright holders legal rights.

It is illegal for anyone to violate any of the rights provided by the copyright law to the owner of copyright. These rights, however, are not unlimited in scope. Sections 107 through 121 of the 1976 Copyright Act establish limitations on these rights. In some cases, these limitations are specified exemptions from copyright liability. One major limitation is the doctrine of “fair use,” which is given a statutory basis in section 107 of the 1976 Copyright Act.

I don't know how far you want to take this but you might have a case if you come under the fair use doctrine.

See the link below for more information.

Source(s):

4 years ago
  • Email

Other Answers

whoever owns the YMCA song gets paid anytime it is broadcast, so they want to prevent unauthorized use on YouTube.

by njyogibear - 4 years ago

well i can't really answer the OP question(s) per se but just today the same media company took down a theatrical trailer for the movie "Can't Stop The Music" that i posted on youtube. at the time of their move, the video clip had garnered thousands of views and quite a bit of user response via comments. all positive, i might add. and all utterly free-of-charge publicity for the "intellectual property" in question. now nobody is being exposed to it or talking about it on youtube. justice prevails!

i do not gain financially in any way from anything - which is pretty much just strictly theatrical trailers for movies, mind you - that i post on youtube. remember when media corporations used to have to pay large sums of money to get the very same trailers for their movie products aired? me too! now it can happen completely for free via internet channels and these media mogul morons (not all) just simply do not get it. they fight the future. i never went to business school, mind you, but i think this kind of takedown represents one of the stupidest intellectual positions i have ever heard of.

i would encourage everyone in the general public to boycott Scorpio Music SA because i think they have clearly demonstrated that they are too freaking stupid to be allowed to continue to be in business.

by deadenddvd - 4 years ago

Recommended Articles

  • Monitors show the value of the Facebook, Inc. stock during morning trading at the NASDAQ Marketsite in New York
    Facebook shares sink 11 percent as reality overtakes hype

    (Reuters) - Facebook shares sank 11 percent in the first day of trading without the full support of the company's underwriters, leaving some investors down almost 25 percent from where they were Friday … More »Facebook shares sink 11 percent as reality overtakes hype

    Monitors show the value of the Facebook, Inc. stock during morning trading at the NASDAQ Marketsite in New York

    (Reuters) - Facebook shares sank 11 percent in the first day of trading without the full support of the company's underwriters, leaving some investors down almost 25 percent from where they were Friday and driving others to switch back to more established stocks. Facebook's debut was beset by problems, so much so that Nasdaq …

  • Employees play table tennis inside the headquarters office of Alibaba (China) Technology Co. Ltd on the outskirts of Hangzhou
    Yahoo clears a hurdle, sells Alibaba stake for $7.1 billion

    SHANGHAI/NEW YORK (Reuters) - Yahoo Inc will sell as much as half of its 40 percent stake in Chinese e-commerce powerhouse Alibaba Group for $7.1 billion, ending years of fractious talks over how to extract … More »Yahoo clears a hurdle, sells Alibaba stake for $7.1 billion

    Employees play table tennis inside the headquarters office of Alibaba (China) Technology Co. Ltd on the outskirts of Hangzhou

    SHANGHAI/NEW YORK (Reuters) - Yahoo Inc will sell as much as half of its 40 percent stake in Chinese e-commerce powerhouse Alibaba Group for $7.1 billion, ending years of fractious talks over how to extract value from its most prized asset. Yahoo also increased its stock buyback authorization by $5 billion to $5.5 billion …

  • Traders work on the floor of the New York Stock Exchange
    Wall Street rebounds, but investors dump Facebook

    NEW YORK (Reuters) - Stocks rose more than 1 percent on Monday, with the S&P 500 snapping a six-day losing streak in a rebound from equities' biggest weekly drop in almost six months, but Facebook slumped … More »Wall Street rebounds, but investors dump Facebook

    Traders work on the floor of the New York Stock Exchange

    NEW YORK (Reuters) - Stocks rose more than 1 percent on Monday, with the S&P 500 snapping a six-day losing streak in a rebound from equities' biggest weekly drop in almost six months, but Facebook slumped in its second session after a disappointing debut. Tech shares were among the day's biggest gainers, with an S&P sector …

  • Two men stand in front of an Apple logo outside an Apple store in Shanghai
    Apple still dominates world's top brands: study

    (Reuters) - Apple has maintained its place as the world's most valuable brand over the past year, leading a group of technology-related companies that dominate the top 10, according to a study published … More »Apple still dominates world's top brands: study

    Two men stand in front of an Apple logo outside an Apple store in Shanghai

    (Reuters) - Apple has maintained its place as the world's most valuable brand over the past year, leading a group of technology-related companies that dominate the top 10, according to a study published on Tuesday. The iPhone and iPad maker has boosted its brand value by 19 percent in the past year to $183 billion, or 37 …

  • A bank clerk counts U.S. dollar banknotes on bundles of 100 Chinese yuan banknotes at a branch of a bank in Huaibei
    Exclusive: U.S. lets China bypass Wall Street for Treasury orders

    NEW YORK (Reuters) - China can now bypass Wall Street when buying U.S. government debt and go straight to the U.S. Treasury, in what is the Treasury's first-ever direct relationship with a foreign government, … More »Exclusive: U.S. lets China bypass Wall Street for Treasury orders

    A bank clerk counts U.S. dollar banknotes on bundles of 100 Chinese yuan banknotes at a branch of a bank in Huaibei

    NEW YORK (Reuters) - China can now bypass Wall Street when buying U.S. government debt and go straight to the U.S. Treasury, in what is the Treasury's first-ever direct relationship with a foreign government, according to documents viewed by Reuters. The relationship means the People's Bank of China buys U.S. debt using …

  • In this photo illustration, a Facebook logo on a computer screen is seen through glasses held by a woman in Bern
    Silicon Valley takes Facebook fizzle in stride

    SAN FRANCISCO (Reuters) - Facebook's lackluster initial public offering performance is a black eye for many on Wall Street and could have ramifications for similar upcoming deals such as an offering by … More »Silicon Valley takes Facebook fizzle in stride

    In this photo illustration, a Facebook logo on a computer screen is seen through glasses held by a woman in Bern

    SAN FRANCISCO (Reuters) - Facebook's lackluster initial public offering performance is a black eye for many on Wall Street and could have ramifications for similar upcoming deals such as an offering by Twitter, but venture capitalists in Silicon Valley are keen to shrug off Facebook's stumble - at least for now. ...

  • Rajat Gupta, a former Goldman Sachs Group Inc and Procter & Gamble board member, departs after leaving the Manhattan Federal Court in New York
    Flurry of arguments start Gupta insider-trading trial

    NEW YORK (Reuters) - Former Goldman Sachs director Rajat Gupta "threw away his duties" by divulging bank secrets to hedge fund manager Raj Rajaratnam, a U.S. prosecutor said at the start of Gupta's insider-trading … More »Flurry of arguments start Gupta insider-trading trial

    Rajat Gupta, a former Goldman Sachs Group Inc and Procter & Gamble board member, departs after leaving the Manhattan Federal Court in New York

    NEW YORK (Reuters) - Former Goldman Sachs director Rajat Gupta "threw away his duties" by divulging bank secrets to hedge fund manager Raj Rajaratnam, a U.S. prosecutor said at the start of Gupta's insider-trading trial on Monday. The defense punched back that the government had no direct evidence. Gupta, 63, once a boldface …

  • Shoppers cart their purchases from a Wal-Mart store in Mexico City
    U.S. lawmakers frustrated in Wal-Mart corruption probe

    WASHINGTON (Reuters) - U.S. lawmakers investigating Wal-Mart Stores Inc for alleged bribery in Mexico are frustrated by the lack of cooperation they have received from the company, a committee staffer … More »U.S. lawmakers frustrated in Wal-Mart corruption probe

    Shoppers cart their purchases from a Wal-Mart store in Mexico City

    WASHINGTON (Reuters) - U.S. lawmakers investigating Wal-Mart Stores Inc for alleged bribery in Mexico are frustrated by the lack of cooperation they have received from the company, a committee staffer familiar with the investigation said. Attorneys for Wal-Mart briefed the committee earlier on Monday about the company's …

  • Facebook Inc. CEO Mark Zuckerberg is seen on a screen televised from their headquarters in Menlo Park moments after their IPO launch in New York
    Insight: Morgan Stanley cut Facebook estimates just before IPO

    (Reuters) - In the run-up to Facebook's $16 billion IPO, Morgan Stanley, the lead underwriter on the deal, unexpectedly delivered some negative news to major clients: The bank's consumer Internet analyst, … More »Insight: Morgan Stanley cut Facebook estimates just before IPO

    Facebook Inc. CEO Mark Zuckerberg is seen on a screen televised from their headquarters in Menlo Park moments after their IPO launch in New York

    (Reuters) - In the run-up to Facebook's $16 billion IPO, Morgan Stanley, the lead underwriter on the deal, unexpectedly delivered some negative news to major clients: The bank's consumer Internet analyst, Scott Devitt, was reducing his revenue forecasts for the company. The sudden caution very close to the huge initial …

  • Some investors still await confirmation on Facebook orders

    NEW YORK (Reuters) - Some customers of Fidelity Investments, Morgan Stanley and Charles Schwab are still waiting to see if their trades for Facebook shares were completed on Friday. Massive demand for … More »Some investors still await confirmation on Facebook orders

    NEW YORK (Reuters) - Some customers of Fidelity Investments, Morgan Stanley and Charles Schwab are still waiting to see if their trades for Facebook shares were completed on Friday. Massive demand for the social networking giant's initial public offering on Friday, which set a trading volume record for U.S. market debuts, …

  • Facebook stock slide puts new pressures on company

    SAN FRANCISCO (Reuters) - Facebook Inc's underwhelming debut on Wall Street increases the pressure on the social networking giant to deliver stellar growth - a novel situation for Chief Executive Mark … More »Facebook stock slide puts new pressures on company

    SAN FRANCISCO (Reuters) - Facebook Inc's underwhelming debut on Wall Street increases the pressure on the social networking giant to deliver stellar growth - a novel situation for Chief Executive Mark Zuckerberg, who has been clear he is more interested in building products than making money. Facebook shares fell 11 percent …

  • Eaton to buy Cooper Industries for $11.8 billion

    (Reuters) - Diversified industrial manufacturer Eaton Corp struck a deal to buy electrical equipment maker Cooper Industries Plc for $11.8 billion in cash and stock and said it would shift its incorporation … More »Eaton to buy Cooper Industries for $11.8 billion

    (Reuters) - Diversified industrial manufacturer Eaton Corp struck a deal to buy electrical equipment maker Cooper Industries Plc for $11.8 billion in cash and stock and said it would shift its incorporation to Ireland to save on taxes. The deal, Eaton's biggest ever, will allow the company to offer a broader range of electrical …

  • Nasdaq announces plan for unfilled Facebook orders

    NEW YORK (Reuters) - Nasdaq has engaged federal regulators to untangle the problems that occurred at the opening of Facebook Inc's initial public offering on Friday that could eventually result in financial … More »Nasdaq announces plan for unfilled Facebook orders

    NEW YORK (Reuters) - Nasdaq has engaged federal regulators to untangle the problems that occurred at the opening of Facebook Inc's initial public offering on Friday that could eventually result in financial restitution for investors who did not get shares at the desired price. The Financial Industry Regulatory Authority …

  • A man walks past a branch of Barclays bank in central London
    Barclays to sell $6.1 billion BlackRock stake

    LONDON (Reuters) - British bank Barclays is selling its near-20 percent stake in U.S. asset manager BlackRock, worth $6.1 billion, as tougher global regulations have cut the attraction of such holdings. … More »Barclays to sell $6.1 billion BlackRock stake

    A man walks past a branch of Barclays bank in central London

    LONDON (Reuters) - British bank Barclays is selling its near-20 percent stake in U.S. asset manager BlackRock, worth $6.1 billion, as tougher global regulations have cut the attraction of such holdings. Barclays has held the stake for almost three years, a legacy of BlackRock's $15 billion purchase of Barclays Global Investors, …

  • Early Facebook mutual fund buyers still in money

    (Reuters) - Fidelity Investments and other big mutual fund families that were early backers of Facebook Inc are likely still winners despite the social network's troubled stock market debut. Facebook shares … More »Early Facebook mutual fund buyers still in money

    (Reuters) - Fidelity Investments and other big mutual fund families that were early backers of Facebook Inc are likely still winners despite the social network's troubled stock market debut. Facebook shares were priced at $38 per share in its initial public offering on Thursday. Despite an initial bump in their market debut …